As a fellow combiner (with a side order of tool bulding), I have to disagree. There is definitely a future in academia for combiner, they just won't be called "bioinformaticians", and rather will just be called "biologists".
Combiners absolutely can and should be leading research, as I do. Yes, I need some collaboration to generate data, but this is generally done as a quid pro quo for me supervising the analysis of their data.
@IanSudbery many good points all around. I think one way to succeed as a "combiner" is to focus more on the biological goal/question. I stopped identifying primarily as a bioinformatician because it felt like I was emphasizing the methods I use rather than the goal, per se.
Yes, this is my approach in general. Unless I'm talking to people who do identify as bioinformaticians. As @gedankenstuecke said, a sort of code switching.
I think this points to a more general point that people who make their entire professional existance about a particular approach or technique are probably painting themselves into a corner that will hamstring their career. Whether this is bioinformatics, or something else.
Ian Sudbery
in reply to Philipp Bayer • • •As a fellow combiner (with a side order of tool bulding), I have to disagree. There is definitely a future in academia for combiner, they just won't be called "bioinformaticians", and rather will just be called "biologists".
Combiners absolutely can and should be leading research, as I do. Yes, I need some collaboration to generate data, but this is generally done as a quid pro quo for me supervising the analysis of their data.
Frank Aylward
in reply to Ian Sudbery • • •Ian Sudbery
in reply to Frank Aylward • • •Yes, this is my approach in general. Unless I'm talking to people who do identify as bioinformaticians. As @gedankenstuecke said, a sort of code switching.
I think this points to a more general point that people who make their entire professional existance about a particular approach or technique are probably painting themselves into a corner that will hamstring their career. Whether this is bioinformatics, or something else.
Bastian Greshake Tzovaras
in reply to Ian Sudbery • • •