Skip to main content


Last November I was approached by Dublin City University (DCU) to be one of five artists in residence creating work for a project called SEED.

The brief is to create an artwork that presents complex environmental data without prioritising the sense of vision in the artwork. As a **visual** artist, this is obviously a challenge.

Even more challenging – it is at the artists' discretion what data to use. Sometimes having no limitation on a project can just make it more daunting.

1/?

This entry was edited (2 months ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

I've used smell, touch and sound in works before, so it's not new ground for me, but I don't think I've ever prioritised these other senses. Visual is my method. So I relish the challenge.

The first problem, however, has been to find data that tells enough of a story. I figure if I can find the data set, then the method should come to me.

2/?

This entry was edited (2 months ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

In December, I was reading the popular science book 'The High Seas' by Olive Heffernan and came across a reference to the 'Continuous Plankton Recorder'.

This strange device looks like a metal duck and swims in the ocean, dragged behind large and small fishing vessels. It catches (and squashes) tiny plankton onto a silk screen, and these are later counted to show the populations in different waters.

The experiment began in 1931, and is still running today. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuo…

3/?

in reply to Fionnáin

The CPR is interesting for a few reasons. It was the first device to pick up plastic floating in the ocean in 1965, and in the late 1960s it began to record microplastics in the ocean. There is now a 65-year plus record of microplastic increase as a result of these devices, with a 95-year record of plankton recording.

I decided this was my dataset (with agreement from the team at DCU).

4/?

This entry was edited (2 months ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

I'm not sure why I'm recording this here. I guess sometimes my process is a bit of a mystery to colleagues and friends, so I thought I'd write it up a little. I'm at the stage now where I'm trying to figure out how to present that data in a non-visual form.

5/?

in reply to Fionnáin

My earliest thoughts have been about water. Water as a sensing device, as something you touch, and as a visual medium too (not prioritising visual doesn't mean not using it).

My other thought has been about tension, particularly how stress in one area creates tension in another.

Finally, about plankton, who are crucial to food webs across the ocean. Where their numbers reduce, so do fish, whale, mollusc and other species'. They are keystone in ocean environments.

6/?

in reply to Fionnáin

I've done some experiments using a linear actuator to tension a cello string across a glass fish enclosure that I used in a past project. It sounds and feels good, and I think this will work for the 'output' of the work.

For how the audience might provide input, I was struggling until last Monday when I met Dr Trish Morgan, who is running the project. I wanted human interference to be the trigger. She suggested another box with water that people could move, touch, change. I like this.

7/?

in reply to Fionnáin

So if the work can somehow show the story behind the data, that one stress in one place creates tension in another, I think I could have a nice artwork.

I also changed my mind on the cello string. Fishing wire makes a lot more sense as a medium. And automating the whole thing with some DIY electronics should be possible, although actuators are maybe overkill for the job.

Lots of testing still needed, but the project ends in April so I'll update here as it develops.

8/TBC

in reply to Fionnáin

the description of how the boats trail a silk screen and material collects on it reminds me of paper-making and felting.
in reply to Raye

@raye yeah the result isn't unlike that. It's beautiful but also pretty upsetting as it kills the plankton that get stuck in the silk, so the process is violent. I want that also to be present in my artwork, a comment on that violence, but I haven't figured that out yet.

It reminds me a bit of a moment in Jacques Cousteau's 'The Silent World' where the crew of the ship drop dynamite into a bay, and then count the numbers of creatures that float to the top to show what 'lives' (lived?) there.

@Raye
in reply to Raye

@raye I've read the whole thread to my teen (A-Level art student) and her first suggestion was a response in felting.

The CPR reminds me of a pasta making machine - sorry, don't mean to be facetious, and not sure where that would lead. Food connection?

@Raye
in reply to Michael ᚋᚔᚉᚆᚓᚐᚂ

@baoigheallain @raye yes, thanks for sharing your thoughts! (and nice approach from your daughter – that's thinking like an artist!).

Felting makes sense, although in my practice it would be more as a research process toward a final artwork.

Pasta machine? Ha, I guess so, if the poor squashed plankton are the unfortunate pasta. I sometimes think of the CPR as a weird sea creature. Food is always part of my work, and is the role of plankton for so many sea creatures; I'll give this some thought

in reply to Fionnáin

@raye

Thanks for the reply.

Her thought was a plankton trapped in felting that would somehow change to plastic over a series of panels.

'You gave my idea away' she has shouted at me.

@Raye
in reply to Michael ᚋᚔᚉᚆᚓᚐᚂ

In my experience, two artists using the same idea will still come up with two completely different outcomes anyway, so you'll just have twice as much good art. Ideas shared just enrich the world.

In line with this: I love her idea. She should make it! It's very clever. She can cite the CPR.

In my practice, I create installations from mixed materials like glass, electronics, video and timber. So even with the same base concepts, our approach will be very different 😀

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

Today I had a conversation with the senior numerical ecologist at the CPR survey and this whole process is fascinating.

Each plankton recorder is boxed up and sent to some port in the world, where it is attached to a ship that has a regular route. The plankton is collected, then boxed up and sent back to Plymouth where a team of 12 analysts observe and tag the individual plankton by hand. Thousands at a time, recorded by hand!

9/?

in reply to Fionnáin

The survey team interpret the data based on their knowledge of plankton behaviours, such as how phytoplankton act at this time of year, at this buoyancy, at this ocean temperature, etc. It takes extraordinarily complex knowledge to understand what to expect and what to look for, and I am out of my depth(!)

I love these complex projects, but I often feel overwhelmed by how amazing human beings are. The labour, expertise and competence is mind-boggling.

10/?

in reply to Fionnáin

This morning I met a staff member from the Irish Marine Institute, who use data from the Continuous Plankton Recorder to estimate fish numbers and to locate algal blooms. It was a fascinating conversation.

The timing of this project is really rich too, as they are very keen to understand the populations of zooplankton in Irish waters, and they have offered lots of resources (surveys, papers, records). I will be using some of their data in my artwork.

11/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Following my earlier contact, The Marine Institute of Ireland sent me a big bank of academic papers last week that document plankton numbers in the north Atlantic and the Irish Sea.

Although they are too technical for me, the weighted measures used on the data, the methods and the results are fascinating. They show how human-led climate change is having an adverse effect on plankton numbers across this area, although there is a small increase in diversity of zooplankton.

12/?

in reply to Fionnáin

These are the types of climate stories that never really make headlines, because the research is too complex. They don't make good news, but they are the most important stories.

As an artist, this is also hard to present. I can make an artwork that tangles up all this complexity, but in my experience this often leads to really confusing or overly cerebral art. Although that type of work has a value, I try to be a little more 'pop' in my work.

13/?

in reply to Fionnáin

One human story that I've been introduced to is that the technicians who analyse plankton numbers in the CPR lab in Plymouth, UK, are mostly nearing retirement. Currently there are 12 technicians working there.

There are only a couple of younger staff trawling through thousands of microscopic images of plankton, hand-tagging each one. It is highly skilled, technical work. Without training new technicians, the CPR data analysis will slow down or stop completely.

14/?

in reply to Fionnáin

I often think about audience at this stage. I once saw Suzie Quatro give an interview on TV where she said the hardest gigs to play were the bars she played when she was young, with only one or two people leering at her. If she could reach them, then 60,000 people at a festival was easy.

My parents are intelligent, but always struggle with the complexity of climate science. They are my target audience. If I can help them understand what the CPR tells us, I'm sure I'll make something good.

15/?

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

I need to know a little more about the Continuous Plankton Recorder technicians in Plymouth, and am now looking into how I can visit there, ideally in the next few weeks.

I'm also going to visit the Irish Marine Institute, because a lot more comes of being on-site than of reading from a distance.

(reading these posts back and I notice what a wriggly path these projects can bring me on – and I just drift around like plankton in a current)

16/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Alister Hardy was a marine biologist and also an artist. He travelled on the RRS Discovery in 1925-27, and it was there he invented the continuous plankton recorder.

His paintings and drawings of aquatic critters are really alive. Later in life he became a noted scholar in religious experiences, which might seem like a bit of a leap in another direction, but it makes sense to me.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alister_…

17/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Since I started this project, I have been reading a lot of moral philosophy and a little theology. I find this coincidence a little spooky.

Last week, a friend @mrvi said that the ocean is a place that invites us to forget our hubris, because it is too big and awesome. I agree, and this is why the leap from plankton to religious experience makes sense to me.

18/?

@VI
in reply to Fionnáin

I've arranged a visit to Plymouth later this month to visit the laboratory where they analyse plankton samples, and the workshop where they make CPR devices.

After arranging this, I went looking for a copy of Hardy's out-of-press book about Plankton, which he both wrote and illustrated, and found a used copy in a booksellers online. I was going to order it, but I looked up the address and it's less than an hour away from Plymouth. So I'll go and get it in person.

Another odd coincidence.

19/?

in reply to Fionnáin

I got another of Alister Hardy's books, 'Great Waters', from the library and it's a precious object. I'm excited to read it.

In the introduction it references the 'Reports from the RRS Discovery' series and I went looking online. I found out that the entire 32 volumes, published between 1931 and 1964, were scanned and put online in 2008!

I know there is a lot of negativity about the internet these days, but this type of resource is why I love the world wide web: biodiversitylibrary.org/biblio…

20/?

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

I'm still playing with materials while doing all this research.

My thoughts are still around building some kind of tension-based artwork, and I've been experimenting with creating tension on a cello string using a linear actuator. I tried fishing wire for obvious material reasons, but realised that it's not durable enough to stretch again and again. So I've gone back to musical instrument strings.

Here's a test of an actuator increasing/decreasing tension over a water tank.

21/?

in reply to Fionnáin

'Great Waters' by Alister Hardy tells the story of the 1925 voyage of the RRS DIscovery to the southern oceans.

At one point, Hardy mentions how the 18th Century poem 'Rime of the Ancient Mariner' by Coleridge was written almost entirely by the poet taking quotes from mariners from library books in Bristol. I felt like I had travelled through time, my method following the same process from the Irish Library service.

Here's the quote: bookwyrm.social/user/fionnain/…

22/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Frustratingly, Hardy has cut his journal entries on the first Continuous Plankton Recorder, which is what I hoped to find:

'My journal at this point goes on to record the first trial to be made with an apparatus which I have called the continuous plankton recorder...I shall not record all these trials, but devote a section to them where I describe the machine.'

So I will have to dig further. Maybe that journal still exists somewhere.

I'll continue the book though, it's a great read!

23/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Is 24-posts-and-counting too long a thread?

I wonder if this should become a more concise research document...but then again, this method of recording-while-doing is creating its own interesting artefact. It's a live journal of the investigation, shared with the siphonophore body.

24/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Somewhere within Hardy's book about ocean research I stumbled across a reference to the carcinologist* Isabella Gordon (misspelled Isrbella Gordon) and went looking for more information. What a fascinating Wikipedia history, including the limerick! I'd love to know more.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isabella…

*carcinology: study of crustaceans

25/?

in reply to Fionnáin

I just arrived in the UK en route to the CPR Lab in Plymouth. I'm borrowing a friend's car in Bristol — I wanted to use public transport but it won't work with the limited routes to the places I need to visit, and the limited time I have.

I will have a little spare time and will walk the Dartmouth river walk out to the coast, following the route of the RRS Discovery's launch 101 years ago.

I'm very open to recommendations of places to walk in or near Plymouth!

26/?

in reply to Fionnáin

lovely! You might spot seals on the River Dart. Nearer Plymouth you might like a coast walk at Noss Mayo southwestcoastpath.org.uk/walk…

Or head inland to Dartmoor. Lydford Gorge is pretty spectacular. Or the remains of an abandoned medieval village at Hound Tor - there’s a good circular walk from Hay Tor roostandroam.co.uk/haytor-rock… (sorry about the ads on this one).

in reply to Fionnáin

@helenclayton Lydford Gorge was wonderful, thank you for that suggestion. Although the devil's cauldron was closed, the waterfall walk was still really nice and I heard some woodpeckers.

Ditto Noss Mayo; what an amazing town with such unique geography. I walked a good chunk of the forest walk as the sun set.

Unfortunately I couldn't get near the Dart because of a series of road closures which left me a bit panicky on the way back to the airport. Something left aside for my next visit.

in reply to Fionnáin

oh I’m so glad you got out and about. For some reason I’d thought you were going to the Dart first. Hadn’t considered you might be headed back that way from Plymouth. Part of the main coast road was taken out in January storms and I can well imagine the nightmare road diversions and panic of getting to the airport. The country lanes are very narrow and convoluted! I’m so sorry you missed out but maybe next time!
in reply to Helen Clayton

@helenclayton I had actually planned the Dart walk first, but changed my plans when I laid it all out. It was a bit too far to go when I was meeting someone in Launceton the same afternoon.

Yes I encountered that storm damage. It's unreal! The country lanes were an experience themselves.

in reply to Fionnáin

ah yes, that would be a trek to launceston.

Devon lanes are an experience. I was born and raised there but even I can get a bit panicked when there’s a lot of traffic.

in reply to Helen Clayton

@helenclayton I enjoyed it for the most part. It's not too unlike where I'm from in northwest Ireland, except for the potholes. Whoo-ee some of them seem to go down into the earth's core!
in reply to Fionnáin

Plymouth is next door to Dartmoor, which has innumerable walks. Norsworthy Bridge by the Burrator Reservoir is a good starting point.
The South West Coast Path between Dartmouth and Plymouth has some of the most spectacular coastal scenery you could wish for. I have a particular fondness for the stretch between Start Point and Salcombe.
in reply to Andy Hort

@Devonkiwi great! That coastal walk might suit my movements perfectly. And also nice to get recommendations for Dartmoor — I was finding the selection a bit daunting. Thank you!
in reply to Fionnáin

Glad to have been of help. If you do the coastal walk, try The Pig's Nose Inn at East Prawle for lunch. It used to be my local: the best pub in Devon!
in reply to Andy Hort

@Devonkiwi wonderful, I will put that on the list. I have to see how quickly I get done with work on Wednesday but if I am finished early, I'll prioritise this walk. I'll let you know here how I got on.
in reply to Fionnáin

@Devonkiwi I never made it to Dartmouth or to East Prawle. For some bizarre reason I hit four road closures and only managed a short hike near Strete Gate (which was really nice!) before having to rush back to the airport in Bristol.

One road is destroyed by a storm, two more had roadworks, and just when I thought I was finished spinning down narrow country lanes, there was a closure for a lorry crash. Weird day.

But thanks again for the recommendations!

in reply to Fionnáin

That's a shame. Slapton Line (the road between Strete and Torcross) took a real battering from the winter storms, and I guess the back lanes struggle to close that gap.
I'm glad you were able to see some of South Devon anyway.
in reply to Andy Hort

@Devonkiwi it was still lovely.

And I will be back in the coming year, so I'll get another crack at it.

in reply to Fionnáin

I just spent the day at the CPR Lab in Plymouth.

I was shown the process for unwinding silk to reveal plankton samples for analysis. I watched plankton swimming in a microscope. I read through the Discovery Series of publications in their original print form from the 1930s and 40s.

I have arrived back to my accommodation barely able to keep my eyes open – it was a lot to take in but a great day. This hands on research has already been so rewarding, and I'm glad I've made this trip.

27/?

in reply to Fionnáin

And then there were the people...

One person has been researching jellyfish since 1963. Another two joined the team because of a tiny ad they saw in the newspaper in the 90s. Five of the analysts joined the team last September, and are still learning the ropes, but are incredibly knowledgeable. One biologist is sequencing the molecular structure of plankton for a different type of monitoring.

Tomorrow morning I'll visit the workshop where the devices are built.

28/?

in reply to Fionnáin

This morning I went to the workshop where they service and maintain the CPRs in Plymouth, and send them out all over the world. The oldest device that is still being put into the ocean to calculate plankton numbers was built in 1938 (pictured with number '12' on it).

The team liaise with hundreds of volunteers on ships and in ports all over the world to glean data about plankton movement. The workshop is pristene and incredibly efficient.

29/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Here's a single piece of microplastic seen through a microscope in the CPR lab.

30/?

in reply to Fionnáin

Back in the studio now, experimenting with playing videos under water. I like the idea that the hand obscures the image, that touching makes it more difficult to see.

And I want the audience of this artwork to wet their arms. I'm experimenting with conductivity sensors to play and change the videos.

31/?

This entry was edited (6 days ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

Returning to 'Rime of the Ancient Mariner' by Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1834), I read the full text today and think it is an amazing poem, and one so poignant in today's biodiversity crisis that I feel I have to give homage to it in my own artwork, somehow.

The mariner regrets cursing his ship by callously killing an albatross.

"'Is it he?' quoth one, 'Is this the man?
By him who died on cross,
With his cruel bow he laid full low
The harmless Albatross"

poetryfoundation.org/poems/439…

32/?

in reply to Fionnáin

This poem was written a few years after Herman Melville wrote Billy Budd, Sailor (and a couple of decades before Moby Dick). It captures some of the same enchantment with the ship as a technology of far-reaching travel, and also emphasises the weirdness of morality and superstition at sea.

Even today, oceans are so vast and uncontrollable that they evoke mystery. The unfathomable possibilities of the depths are humbling.

33/?

in reply to Fionnáin

When I visited both the Marine Biological Association in Plymouth and the Irish Marine Institute in Galway, I paid attention to how they use complementary data alongside plankton numbers to understand ocean health. In particular, salinity (level of salt), temperature and acidity are measured alongside plankton numbers.

Just as with plankton, these data gathered are the same today as they were 101 years ago on the RRS Discovery.

34/?

in reply to Fionnáin

I try to use sensors in my artworks that are borrowed from the research. Salinity seemed interesting, but I thought it would be expensive to buy and difficult to build a salinity sensor. But it isn't!

Salinity is measured through conductivity. The more salt in the water, the more conductive (corrected — thanks @tfb ).

So salinity is measured by checking how much current runs through the water. This is one of the simplest sensors imaginable, and I built it with two wires and a resistor.

35/?

This entry was edited (20 hours ago)
in reply to Fionnáin

My plan for an artwork for this project is something that is triggered through this conductivity. By putting your hand in the water with one end of the wire, and bringing it close enough to the other, you change which audio and video is playing.

I am still stuck to this idea of getting an audience member to put their hand in water. I like how the first thing this makes anyone do is take a deep breath in.

36/?

in reply to Fionnáin

One of the technicians in Plymouth told me that 50% of all oxygen on earth is produced by phytoplankton.

So every second breath we take is a gift from them.

37/?

in reply to Fionnáin

That's nearly right, but perfectly backwards. Deionised water is a poor conductor. Electrical conduction in water works via ion transport, so the more salt, the more ions, and the higher the conductivity. The higher conductivity means lower resistance, so your measured resistance in ohms goes down, which I'm guessing is what tripped you up
in reply to Thomas

@tfb ah ok, thanks for the correction. I'm grateful for the accuracy.

I will correct the post. As it happens for the artwork it hasn't tripped me up because I was using proximity to create an effect, so it didn't matter if the number was higher or lower, just that it was different. But it's useful for me to understand this.

in reply to Fionnáin

Getting people to put their hand in a tank of water to affect the piece sounds really cool
in reply to Thomas

@tfb thanks, I'm pleased with the idea. It's also unintentionally really funny to me. Two people have already asked me 'but will you not electrocute someone?'

Of course I said, 'well, you never know...'

The gallery risk assessment sheets might be a bit of an adventure.

in reply to Fionnáin

You could put a sign on it indicating low risk of electrocution ... surely that won't raise questions already answered by the sign 😹
in reply to Fionnáin

Be sure to reread it set to the tune of Gilligan's Island 🏝️🎶
in reply to rezmason

@rezmason this sounds like a good plan, and a bit more palatable than the 13-minute Iron Maiden song that is based on the poem. Like a lot of their music it's fun but feels a bit like eating three bowls of ice cream in a row.
in reply to Fionnáin

I, at least, am most grateful that you are sharing this. The dataset is brilliant! And, ahem, speaking as a permanently confused synesthetic, it is pleasant and inspiring to see how you pick up possible affordances and heft them.
in reply to Will Tuladhar-Douglas

@yetiinabox thanks for saying so! I'm not very good for posting on social media, because I often don't know what to say or how to say it, so I lurk and stay quiet. I'm glad if anyone finds this interesting.

And yes, this data is astounding. What a gift that it has been recorded for this long, to give an accurate picture over a near 100-year history.

Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source
Fionnáin

@raye an interesting update to the previous messages – not to belittle the violence here, but it seems that the amount of plankton killed for these records is something akin to the amount a small fish would eat in the same time, per journey. The numbers recorded are extrapolated to estimate populations.

While I am not diminishing the acceptability of violence, I'm glad the recordings are not indiscriminately killing in huge numbers. Just thought I'd update you on this too.

@Raye
in reply to Fionnáin

A fascinating project and collaboration. Congratulations on being one of the chosen artists. Thanks for sharing the process.
in reply to Ciara

@CiaraNi thank you! I'm delighted to be involved, and I appreciate the kind words.

I realised a while ago when talking to someone on here that what I do as an artist is often opaque, so I thought it would be an interesting journey to write this up as it happens.

I'll keep going too – the project officially ends in mid-April, although I will probably be making artworks from the research for a long time beyond that.

in reply to Fionnáin

Enjoy the project and process! I will enjoy following along.
Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source
Fionnáin
@raye yes, thankfully. I will include this in the artwork anyway, because it's still an important point on ethics even if the violence is minimal. I think it's still important to think about.
@Raye
in reply to Fionnáin

that's fascinating, and about as minimally invasive as you can get for ocean measurements.

Lo, thar be cookies on this site to keep track of your login. By clicking 'okay', you are CONSENTING to this.