Skip to main content



I was wondering why I can’t follow people from Threads on Mastodon and found out it’s because the server I’m on has blocked interoperability with Threads.

Wow, so what are my options here? Nag the admins? Switch my account to a different server? What do I lose if I do that? Which one do I switch to? 🤔

threads.net/@thatadamguy/post/…

in reply to Dare Obasanjo

Absolutely predictable consequence of server operators preemptively blocking Threads. People will either migrate to larger servers that don't, or to Threads altogether. I would hate to see you leave Mastodon even if you were still in my home feed through Threads, simply because I believe Mastodon is the better platform. I hope it doesn't come to it.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron Don't you think this will be a common thing? I wonder if Meta sees the Fediverse as a potential future threat. They tend to quash threats early. E.g. Instagram & WhatsApp. They know it’ll be difficult to get Mastodon users to switch, so their plan is ‘interoperability’, AKA make 95% of the Fediverse Threads profiles. I predict they'll stop short of allowing algorithmic visibility for Mastodon posts, thus enticing a sufficient number to switch, and slowing Fediverse growth.


IMPORTANT. Threads stated policy is to collect and exploit Fediverse user personal data without explicit consent.

Now is a very good time to review Threads Terms of Use (terms.threads.com/terms-of-use) and Supplemental Privacy Policy (help.instagram.com/51523043730…).

Note just by following a Threads user or replying to a post, Meta claims they are entitled to your personal data.

And what do they say they will do with your data? Provide you with "business services (including ads)."

#threads #DataPrivacy

in reply to Mastodon Migration

Your username, profile picture, and domain and IP of your server are public and every Mastodon server out there does absolutely the same thing.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron I still have a lot of concerns that by making something public, that anyone finding it considers themselves entitled to use it for any purpose. I suspect there are several content licenses that provide solutions. It's probably not a Mastodon concern, but maybe it's something that belongs in ActivityPub.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron Yes, but this does not address the issue. The concern expressed here is the use of this identity data, as well as Mastodon user content and interactions, for the purpose of Threads broader business services, including ads.

As described in the document Supplemental Privacy Policy: help.instagram.com/51523043730…

#threads #DataPrivacy

in reply to Mastodon Migration

So theoretically a Threads user might see an ad about honey because they follow a user from beekeepers.ninja.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron but then beekeepers.ninja would probably be blocked by instance moderators.
in reply to rexum

@rexum I think you misunderstood something at some point. The only people who might see ads are people who use the Threads app. There is no way for Threads to show an ad outside of Threads.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron yes, but they could inject ads as user posts but I don't think they would do that.
in reply to rexum

@rexum That would be pointless. You would simply unfollow the user.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron @rexum

Think that the focus on ads misses the point. The primary issue is not the display of ads, but rather the collection and analysis of Fediverse user personal data and content, and the use of it for profiling the user. The concern is that such data is taken from the Fediverse and is used to fill out Meta's profile of the user and then exploited for whatever purpose, including but not at all limited to ads.

in reply to Mastodon Migration

@rexum Personal data usually carries a slightly different meaning than a public profile and posts you choose to broadcast to the open web, and the way this entire thread is written is highly misleading in a disappointing way.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron @rexum Would welcome the opportunity to clarify the matter then. What Threads policy says is that they can use this Third Party Information, whatever you want to call it, for their business purposes. One of the concerns that Fediverse users have is the Terms of Use that platforms like Threads employ, and which Mastodon does not. It would be great for Threads to clarify that they will not exploit Fediverse user data and content in the same way they do users who sign up for their service.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron

Please see the conversation below and the clarifications above.

It seems that Threads has two versions of their Supplemental Privacy Policy. The EU version does not raise concerns, but the US version does. Further, the fact there are two different versions, confirms that the matter is a real concern.

Raising this issue is not "against" Threads integration. Lots of good can come from big players joining distributed social media, but only if we can protect our data privacy rights.

in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron @rexum unless threads injects the ads into the stream of someone we follow on threads. I do not trust Meta.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron
Sure they can. Remember the email services that append ads to emails?
I don’t understand the business plan of Threads, other than acquiring user data to resell. Letting users take their followers and content is a tell that it isn’t about walling in threads with a moat. Rather maybe to expand Threads moat to the entire Fediverse?
It’s very puzzling.
Thank you for your work and insights.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron I can already think of one way if they are devious enough - If I follow someone on threads, then threads can just insert sponsored posts into their timeline that auto syndicates over to my account on Mastodon - So Threads can generate advertising posts on behalf of people and make them look like normal posts which will come across - Twitter essentially did this at one point & may still be doing it to fool people into reading ads
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron The bigger concern would be that a Fediverse user might start getting ads on other platforms about honey, just because they follow someone on Threads and also follow beekeepers.ninja or simply post on Mastodon about bees.

But this is not just about ads. It is about data privacy and what Meta claims authority to do with data and content pulled from the Fediverse.

in reply to Mastodon Migration

No, that is not a concern, because there is no capability for the fediverse user to get ads on other platforms connected to them in any way. It is also an extremely bog standard, matter of fact privacy policy. Ours does not look much different.
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron Why not, and beekeper@threads.net will probably not even know that he boosted that add. 🤷
in reply to Eugen Rochko

While it's true that every well-written social network pricacy policy does cover this kind of data, no it's not at all "absolutely the same thing".

Compare and contrast what Threads' privacy policy says they can do with this data to a privacy policy like @admin's and it's clear that Threads' privacy policy tries to give the company as much ability to use data without requesting additional consent (although EU DPC's may have something to say about it). Also, unlike every Mastodon server out there, Meta's business model relies on exploiting people's data -- and they have a long track record of using data without consent. It really isn't the same thing at all.

eupolicy.social/privacy-policy

Also you suggested elsewhere in this thread that "Personal data usually carries a slightly different meaning than a public profile and posts you choose to broadcast to the open web." In the EU, GDPR is very explicit that personal data includes publicly available data such as this.

@mastodonmigration @rexum

This entry was edited (2 years ago)
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron the difference is: fediverse instances belong (mostly) to communities, whereas f ones belong to a corporation. are you ignoring that fact on purpose?

@mastodonmigration




@Gargron how does federation with @mosseri work? `curl acct:mosseri@threads.net" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">threads.net/.well-known/webfin…` returns `https://www.threads.net/ap/users/mosseri/` which is not a valid AP Person for me
This entry was edited (2 years ago)
in reply to Eugen Rochko

@mosseri

Ah I've seen this with I think gotosocial (and Mastodon secure mode) as well. The status codes (404 in browser and 200 with curl) were throwing me off. Thanks!



Research Physical Scientist Tra-My Justine Richardson nasa.gov/image-article/researc… #NASA
#NASA


Nextcloud's partnership with Roundcube contributes to the broader trend of decentralizing global IT.

@Karlitschek and Thomas Brüderli, head of Roundcube, guide the project towards a new phase, fostering its success as a leading open-source email platform.

We envision a future for #Roundcube centered on user empowerment by welcoming new talent, initiating fresh discussions with contributors, and making new investments.

Join the discussion on our community forum! help.nextcloud.com/t/welcome-r…



120th Anniversary of the First Powered, Controlled Flight nasa.gov/image-article/120th-a… #NASA #Aeronautics #IngenuityHelicopter


Sierra Space’s Dream Chaser New Station Resupply Spacecraft for NASA nasa.gov/missions/station/comm… #NASA #CommercialResupply #General #InternationalSpaceStationISS #ISSResearch


Migrar no es un crimen.

Las políticas que facilitan la vigilancia indiscriminada de personas migrantes se brincan el principio de inocencia.

Únete al lanzamiento de la Coalición Latinoamericana #MigrarSinVigilancia

📅 18 de diciembre
⌚ 11 AM (México/Centroamérica)
📍Youtube

Info: migrarsinvigilancia.org



Work with your cloud-based faves in a Snap
omgubuntu.co.uk/2023/12/ubuntu…
in reply to omg! ubuntu

What about `sudo snap install nextcloud-desktop-client` ?

ℹ️ snapcraft.io/nextcloud-desktop…

We need to keep our FOSS-loving awareness that there's more than just the big GSuite and MS365..



🔒 TechCrunch's analysis of the 23andMe breach highlights the vulnerability of personal genetic data, raising concerns about data protection and transparency.

What do you think about this new case of a user data breach by a company revealing sensitive user data? And what steps do you take to ensure the security of your sensitive information? Share your thoughts and experiences with us!

#CyberSecurityAwareness #DataSecurity #DigitalPrivacy

techcrunch.com/2023/12/04/23an…



Sierra Space’s Dream Chaser New Station Resupply Spacecraft for NASA nasa.gov/missions/station/comm… #NASA #CommercialResupply #General #InternationalSpaceStationISS


Liz Danzico with a lovely write-up of the walk and talk we participated in last week in Thailand. “Empathy means that you travel out of yourself a little or expand.” bobulate.com/2023/12/expanding…


Kennedy Space Center’s NASA Causeway Bridge Construction nasa.gov/image-article/kennedy… #NASA #KennedySpaceCenter #SustainabilityAtKennedySpaceCenter


NASA Geologist Paves the Way for Building on the Moon nasa.gov/centers-and-facilitie… #NASA #MarshallSpaceFlightCenter


RNA-guided RNA silencing by an Asgard archaeal Argonaute biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/20…


The National Science Foundation has issued a notice about the use of generative AI in the NSF merit review process: new.nsf.gov/news/notice-to-the…

#AI #Research #Science


in reply to Andrea Grandi 🦕

It’s been around for a while. It pops up if you scroll away from a video that’s still playing.


With all the dropbox kerfuffle this week (so you don’t mind if we share your private docs with other companies without asking do you? Kthxbye!), has anyone used sync.com ? Decent pricing, decent independent review ( tomsguide.com/reviews/synccom-… ).
This entry was edited (2 years ago)
in reply to Nextcloud 📱☁️💻

@nextcloud
Nextcloud seems to be working well on my PC but my Mac gives me errors when uploading large files. I may investigate it more later but these next few weeks are too busy.


Last day of #AXIES2023 and starting up with, "Utilizing #OpenSource software in LearningAnalytics," from the Open Source technology committee.

I've seen several @sakailms presentations, posters, and vendors. Also there's a nice bit of @moodle love here too!

#EdTech #HigherEd #Moodle #SakaiLMS #EdTechChat #OpenEdTech #HigherEducation

in reply to Patrick Masson

you better reach out to Kyushu Institute of Technology. Looks like an excellent case study for creating a "Data Lake" using #NextCloud withinh academic and research institutions.
in reply to Patrick Masson

Sounds fascinating Patrick, thank you. We love hearing all the novel uses of Nextcloud! -B


If you recently joined Threads because of the Europe thing, I’ve (reluctantly) been trying to use it more, because I’ve missed some of my people. You can follow me here: threads.net/@rickymondello


There's something about Bethesda's (nowadays flawed) approach to an RPG that keeps pulling me back to #Starfield time and again. Especially on the OLED Deck :steamdeck:, even though I spend most of my time playing through GeForce Now. 👀

#Steam #SteamDeck #OLED #SteamDeckOLED #Bethesda #Fallout #Skyrim #Geforce #Nvidia #GeforceNow #GFN #PC #Gaming #Handheld #Tech



Betelgeuse Eclipsed

Image Credit & Copyright: Sebastian Voltmer

apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap231215.ht… #APOD

#APOD
in reply to (moving) APOD

you’ve gone and said it twice in the same post. What if you’d accidentally said it a third time? So irresponsible.


This sign should be on everyone's desk.
It's perfect just the way it is!


The worst Dutch brand slogan of 2023

The Dutch marketing campaign for Pampers diapers also used a pun combining Dutch and English. Their slogan, “Niet bang voor een KAKastrofe!” translates closely to, “Don’t fear a CRAPtastrophe!”

in reply to Muse

The UK version of the Pampers slogan is "Never fear a poonami again"...


Betelgeuse Eclipsed apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap231215.ht… #APOD
#APOD


Giving KDE Plasma 6 A Unique Identity #Linux #YouTube youtu.be/nuqoRPwjhkc


Whenever I see someone whining about me not using Dark Reader and the screen blinding them I think back to when I first discovered online game guides and you'd often be sent to GameFAQs, you'll survive, get over it
in reply to Brodie Robertson

if light mode is making your eyes hurt, you are watching the screen having not enough ambient lighting. Switch on your desk/bedside lamp.
in reply to Brodie Robertson

reminds me of over a decade ago when i printed out an ENTIRE gamefaq of ocarina of time because we didnt have reliable internet at home. i was a computer n00b at the time and didnt know anything about saving an html page for offline use. i kept the printout in a binder. it was over 300 pages long and used up an ink cartridge and a half at least. bless that god damn site.


This was put on a list for humorous translations.
It works perfectly well here in Melbourne, because we have a suburb named "Sunshine". That could be a train sign!
In Adelaide they have a suburb called "Happy Valley". I always wonder if it's a bit "Stepford Wives".


Hi. I'm Emanuel. I'm a photographer and writer from Cleveland, Ohio. I also like crafting cocktails in my dining room and I love plain kettle chips.




LIVE SOON:

Have you guys looked at the art category on Twitch, it's kind of wild. Any way we're going to play more #Neptunia

youtube.com/watch?v=Kcbx-N4m26…




NASA: Una jugosa historia de tomates en la Estación Espacial Internacional nasa.gov/missions/station/iss-… #NASA #ISSResearch #InternationalSpaceStationISS #NASAEnEspañol


Kumataro Ito’s Illustrations of Nudibranchs from the USS Albatross’ Philippine Expedition (ca. 1908). “The roughly 3,000 species in the family nudibranchia [come] in a delightful, dizzying array of shapes, patterns and colours.” publicdomainreview.org/collect…


NASA Awards Turbofan Engine Core Technology Demonstration Contract nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-awa… #NASA
#NASA


Inventor of Air Conditioning Helped Chill NASA Wind Tunnels nasa.gov/centers-and-facilitie… #NASA #GlennResearchCenter


Scary games bundle back for 48 hours: humblebundle.com/games/scary-g… (partner link)
in reply to Liam @ GamingOnLinux 🐧🎮

You mean games that abuse jumpscares and don't make a single effort to actually scare you without jumpscares


NASA: Let’s Ketchup on International Space Station Tomato Research nasa.gov/missions/station/nasa… #NASA #InternationalSpaceStationISS #Expedition70 #General #ISSResearch

Lo, thar be cookies on this site to keep track of your login. By clicking 'okay', you are CONSENTING to this.