Escapism isn't what if used to be. The era of bleakness porn has given way to the era of sophisticated, well-crafted bleakness...
“I think they brought back movie-going. What an event the second [Dune] was,” Pugh cheerfully told the New York Times. “It was just so lovely to be a part of something that we know is our generational kind of Star Wars.”Ponder this for a moment. George Lucas’s space opera boasted a hero who wanted to rescue his friends and free the galaxy from tyranny. Denis Villeneuve’s Dune gives us a young aristocrat who arrives in somebody else’s desert and ends up with a personal army so fanatically devoted to his greatness that his girlfriend appears to be the only person still bothering to check whether he has gone completely mad. Star Wars had a vaguely Buddhist mystical order who wanted you to trust your feelings. Dune has one that would prefer you to stop having feelings for anyone whose genetic profile hasn’t already been approved by their committee of sinister space nuns. What does it say about us if this is the defining cosmic fantasy of the modern era?
Well it's worth adding that the Galactic Empire was partly based on the US, though I doubt most western audiences got that (I certainly didn't). It probably just says that miserable times beget miserable fiction. It sure would be nice to have some happy sci-fi movies though... at least we have Andy Weir !
Pugh’s comparison begins to make a bleak sort of sense. In a world where powerful men keep promising to save us from disasters they helped create, the closest thing to escapism is a dictator who can see the future he is ruining, but is unable to stop himself because the whole damn thing looks so utterly glorious in Imax.
If Dune is this generation’s Star Wars, we are all in big trouble
According to Florence Pugh, Denis Villeneuve’s stunningly strange and breathtaking universe is the equivalent to George Lucas’ heroic space opera. Let’s hope notBen Child (the Guardian)